The "patchwork" monarchy of the last Rurikovichs: power, custom, law
The Early Modern is an era when loose and unconsolidated medieval states gradually transformed into early modern ones. These new political formations are traditionally called "centralized". However, were these early modern states really centralized? The author of the article offers his own answer to this question, and, at first glance, this answer may seem paradoxical and unexpected. Based on an analysis of the surviving evidence, annalistic and gleaned from act materials, the author shows on the example of the Russian state of the 15th-16th centuries that the centralization process itself was complex and contradictory, and political reality was sometimes very far from the "noisy" political declarations. In the early modern times, the Russian state was a “patchwork” state, made up of territories with different levels of economic, political, cultural and religious development, with its own peculiar local customs and traditions.
While nobody left any comments to this publication.
You can be first.
Akty sluzhilykh zemlevladeltsev. T. I (1997) [Acts of service landowners. Vol. I]. Arkheograficheskiy centr, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Akty sotsialno-ekonomicheskoy istorii Severo-Vostochnoy Rusi kontsa XIV – nachala XVI v.: V 3 t. T. I (1952) [Acts of the socio-economic history of North-Eastern Rus at the end of the 14th – beginning of the 16th century], Publishing house of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow, USSR (in Russ.).
Alekseev, Yu. G. (1989), Osvobozhdenie Rusi ot ordynskogo iga [Liberation of Rus from the Horde yoke], Nauka, Leningrad, USSR (in Russ.).
Alekseev, Yu. G. (1991), Gosudar vseya Rusi [The Sovereign of All Rus], Nauka, Novosibirsk, Ryssia (in Russ.).
Alekseev, Yu. G. (2007), Pokhody russkikh voysk pri Ivane III [Campaigns of Russian troops under Ivan III], St. Petersburg State University Publishing House, St. Petersburg, Ryssia (in Russ.).
Arakcheev, V. A. (2014), Vlast i zemlya. Pravitelstvennaya politika v otnoshenii sosloviy v Rossii vtoroy poloviny XVI – nachala XVII veka [Power and land. Government policy towards estates in Russia in the second half of the 16th – early 17th centuries], Drevlekhranilische, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Baranov, K. V. (2004), “Note book of the Polotsk campaign of 1562/63”, Russkiy diplomatariy.Vyp. 10 [Russain diplomatarium. Iss. 10], Drevlekhranilische, Moscow, Russia, 119-154 (in Russ.).
Bazilevich, K. V. (2001), Vneshnyaya politika Russkogo tsentralizovannogo gosudarstva. Vtoraya polovina XV veka [Foreign policy of the Russian centralized state. Second half of the 15th century], Territoriya, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Bentsianov, M. M. (2008), “In specific service: service people of Prince Yu. I. Dmitrovsky”, Rossiya i mir: panorama istoricheskogo razvitiya: [Russia and the world: a panorama of historical development], NPMP “Volot” Publ., Ekaterinburg, Russia, 505-521 (in Russ.).
Bentsianov, M. M. (2010), “Service people of Yuri Dmitrovsky. Local politics”, Old Russia. The Questions of Middle Ages, 3 (41), 55-68 (in Russ.).
Bovykin, V. V. (2015), Ocherki po istorii mestnogo samoupravleniya epokhi Ivana Groznogo [Essays on the history of local self-government in the era of Ivan the Terrible], Publishing and Printing Complex “Vesti”, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Dukhovnye i dogovornye gramoty velikikh i udelnykh knyazey XIV–XVI vv. (1950) [Testament and contractual letters of the great and specific princes of the 14th –16th centuries], Publishing house of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Leningrad, USSR (in Russ.).
Elliott, J. H. (1992), “A Europe of Composite Monarchies”, Past & Present, 137: The Cultural and Political Construction of Europe (November), 48-71.
Filyushkin, A. I. (2006), Tituly russkix gosudarey [Titles of Russian sovereigns], Alyans-Arkheo, Moscow, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Filyushkin, A. I. (2009), “Moscow neonatal empire: on the question of the categories of political practice”, Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2, 5-20 (in Russ.).
Gerbershteyn, S. (2008), Zapiski o Moskovii.T. I [Notes on Muscovy], Pamyatniki istoricheskoy mysli, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Gorskiy, A. A. (2004), Rus: ot slavyanskogo rasseleniya do Moskovskogo tsarstva [Rus: from the Slavic Settlement to the Muscovy], Yazyki slavyanskoy kultury, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Gorskiy, A. A. (2016), Russkie zemli v XIII–XIV vekakh: puti politicheskogo razvitiya [Russian lands in the 13th –14th centuries: ways of political devel], Nauka, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Gramoty Velikogo Novgoroda i Pskova (1949) [Diplomas of Veliky Novgorod and Pskov], Publishing House of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Leningrad, USSR (in Russ.).
Henshall, N. (1992), The Myth of Absolutism: Change & Continuity in Early Modern European Monarchy, Longman, London, New York.
Iosif, Voloczkiy (2007), Poslaniya [Messages], Aksion estin, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Ivanishev, N. D. (1849), Zhizn knyazya Andreya Mikhaylovicha Kurbskogo v Litve i na Volyni. T. II [The life of Prince Andrey Mikhailovich Kurbsky in Lithuania and Volhynia. Vol. II.], Lito-printing house Valner, Kiev, Russia (in Russ.).
Kobrin, V. B. (1962), “Two charters granted to the Monster Monastery (XVI century.)”, Zapiski otdela rukopisey.Vyp. 25. [Notes of the Department of manuscripts. Iss. 25], Kniga, Moscow, Russia, 318-322 (in Russ.).
Koenigsberger, H. G. (1978), “Monarchies and Parliaments in Early Modern: Europe Dominium Regale or Dominium Politicum et Regale”, Theory and Society, 5 (2), 191-217.
Kollmann, N. S. (2012), Crime and Punishment in Early Modern Russia, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Krom, M. M. (2005), “Towards an understanding of Moscow politics of the 16th century: discourse and practice of the Russian late medieval monarchy”, Odysseus: a man in history. 2005: Time and space of a holiday. Iss. 17, 283-303 (in Russ.).
Krom, M. M. (2010a), “Vdovstvuyuschee tsarstvo”: politicheskiy krizis v Rossii 30-kh – 40-kh godov XVI veka [“The Dowager Kingdom”: the political crisis in Russia in the 30s–40s of the 16th century], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Krom, M. M. (2010b), Mezh Rusyu i Litvoy. Pogranichnye zemli v sisteme russko-litovskikh otnosheniy kontsa XV – pervoy treti XVI v. [Between Russia and Lithuania. Border lands in the system of Russian-Lithuanian relations at the end of the 15th – the first third of the 16th century], Kvadriga, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Kuchkin, V. A. (2008), “Foremtn and centurions in Ancient Rus”, in: Gorskiy, A. A., Kuchkin, V. A., Lukin, P. V. and Stefanovich, P. S. Drevnyaya Rus. Ocherki politicheskogo i sotsialnogo stroya [Ancient Rus. Essays on the political and social system], Publ. Indrik, Moscow, Russia, 270-425 (in Russ.).
Lakier, A. B. (1847), “The history of the title of sovereigns of Russia”, Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya [Journal of the Ministry of National Education], Ch. LVI, 81-108 (in Russ.).
Levi-Stross, K. (2008), “La Pensée sauvage”, in: Levi Stross, K. Totemizm segodnya. Nepriruchennaya mysl [Totémisme aujourdhui. La Pensée sauvage], Akademicheskiy proekt, Mpscow, Russia, 143-485 (in Russ.).
Milov, L. V. (2001), Velikorusskiy pakhar i osobennosti rossiyskogo istoricheskogo protsessa [Great Russian plowman and features of the Russian historical process], ROSSPEN, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Pamyatniki russkogo prava. T. II. Pamyatniki prava feodalno-razdroblennoy Rusi XII–XV vv. (1953) [Monuments of Russian law. Vol. II. Monuments of law of feudal-fragmented Rus of the 12th –15th centuries], Gosyurizdat, Moscow, USSR (in Russ.).
Pamyatniki russkogo prava. T. III. Pamyatniki prava perioda obrazovaniya Russkogo tsentralizovannogo gosudarstva XIV–XV vv. (1955) [Monuments of Russian law. Vol. III. Monuments of law of the period of formation of the Russian centralized state of the 14th-15th centuries], Gosyurizdat, Moscow, USSR (in Russ.).
Pamyatniki russkogo prava. T. IV. Pamyatniki prava perioda ukrepleniya Russkogo tsentralizovannogo gosudarstva. XV–XVII vv. (1956) [Monuments of Russian law. Vol. IV. Monuments of law of the period of strengthening the Russian centralized state. 15th –17th centuries], Gosyurizdat, Moscow, USSR (in Russ.).
Poe, M. (2002), “The Truth about Muscovy”, Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 3 (3), 473-486.
Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisey. T. VI: Sofiyskaya vtoraya letopis Vyp. 2 (2000) [Complete collection of Russian chronicles. Vol. VI. Iss. 2. Sofia Second Chronicle], Yazyki slavyanskoy kultury, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisey.T. XLIII. Novgorodskaya letopis po spisku P. P. Dubrovskogo (2004) [Complete collection of Russian chronicles. Vol. XLIII: Novgorod Chronicle according to the list of P. P. Dubrovsky], Yazyki slavyanskoy kultury, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisey. T. XXV: Moskovskiy letopisny svod kontsa XV veka (2004) [Complete collection of Russian chronicles. Vol. XXV: Moscow Chronicle of the end of the 15th century], Yazyki slavyanskoy kultury, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Poslaniya Ivana Groznogo (2005) [Messages of Ivan the Terrible], Nauka, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Rossiyskoe zakonodatelstvo X–XX vekov. T. 2. Zakonodatelstvo perioda obrazovaniya i ukrepleniya Russkogo tsentralizovannogo gosudarstva (1984) [Russian legislation of the 10th –20th centuries. Vol. 2. Legislation of the period of formation and strengthening of the Russian centralized state], Yuridicheskaya literature, Moscow, USSR (in Russ.).
Rozanov, S. P. (1904), Materialy po istorii russkikh pchel. Pamyatniki drevney pismennosti i iskusstva. Vyp. CLIV [Materials on the history of Russian Bees. Monuments of ancient writing and art. Iss. CLIV], Obschestvo lyubiteley drevney pismennosti, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Shtaden, G. (2008), Zapiski o Moskovii. T. I [Notes on Muscovy. Vol. 1], Drevlekhranilische, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
“Simons of the Bishop of Tfersky message” (1969), Izbornik. Sbornik proizvedeniy literatury Drevney Rusi [Izbornik. Collection of works of literature of Ancient Rus], Khudozhestvennaya literature, Moscow, USSR (in Russ.).
Sinitsyna, N. V. (1998), Tretiy Rim. Istoki i evolyutsiya russkoy srednevekovoy kontseptsii (XV–XVI vv.) [Third Rome. Origins and evolution of the Russian medieval concept (15th –16th centuries)], Indrik, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Smirnov, A. A. (1994), “The State of the Fighting Nation”, Rodina [Homeland], 9, 34-38 (in Russ.).
Tikhomirov, M. N. (1941), “Little-known chronicle monuments of the 16th century”, Istoricheskie zapiski. T. 10 [Historical notes. Vol. 10], Publishing house of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow, USSR, 84-94 (in Russ.).
Zimin, A. A. (1960), “From the history of central and local government in the 16th century”, Istoricheskiy arkhiv [Historical archive], 3, 144-150 (in Russ.).