Список литературы

2408-932X

Research Result. Social Studies and Humanities

2408-932X

10.18413/2408-932X-2018-4-2-0-2

1444

RESEARCHES

THE EARLY MODERN MUSCOVITE "SUB-TYRRANY" IN MODERN HISTORIOGRAPHY

Penskoy

Vitaly V.

Penskoy

Vitaly V.

penskoy@bsu.edu.ru

Penskaya

Tatiana M.

Penskaya

Tatiana M.

penskaya@bsu.edu.ru

Belgorod State National Research University

2018

4200

This article is a reflection on the nature of the "Great Stereotype," which depicts Russia in early modern times as a despotic Asian state. The authors come to the conclusion that this stereotype is based on the historians' uncritical perception of the evidence of West European travelers, diplomats and adventurers. The reference to the act materials gives a completely different picture. The authors show that in modern Western historiography (and partly in Russia) there has been a stable "revisionist" current. This direction does not reconsider the previous negative assessments of the Moscow early-political political system and regime, and proceeds from the premise that Russia in the early modern period, in its political and legal development, does not fundamentally differ from early Western European states.

Later Middle Agesearly ModernEuropeRussiastatelawcentralizationstrategies of administration

Список литературы

1.       Alekseev, Yu. G. (1991), Gosudar’ vseja Rusi [The Emperor of All Russia], Nauka, Novosibirsk, Russia (in Russ.).

2.       Alekseev, Yu. G. (2001), Sudebnik Ivana III. Tradiciya i reforma [The Court Book by Ivan III. Tradition and Reform], Dmitriy Bulanin, Saint-Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).

3.       Arakcheev, V. A. (2014), Vlast’ i “zemlya”. Pravitelstvennaya politika v otnoshenii tyaglyh sosloviy v Rossii vtoroy poloviny XVI – nachala XVII veka [The power and "ground". Government policy in respect of taxpaying estates in Russia in the second half of the 16th – early 17th century], Drevlehranilishche, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

4.       Bovykin, V. V. (2012), Mestnoe samoupravlenie v Russkom gosudarstve XVI veka [Local government in the Russian state in the XVI century], Dmitrij Bulanin, Saint Petersburg, Russia.

5.       “Dokonchanie of Grand Duke Boris Alexandrovich of Tver with Grand Duke Vitovt of Lithuania” (1950), Duhovnie I dogovornye gramoty velikih udel’nyh knyazey XIV–XVI vv. [Spiritual and Treaty ratification and the Great Princes, the 14-16th centuries], Nauka Publishers, Moscow-Leningrad, USSR, 62-63 (in Russ.).

6.       Dumin, S. V. (1991), “Another Rus (the Great princedom Lithuanian and Russian)” (in Russ.), Istoriya Otechestva: lyudi, idei, reshebiya. Ocherki istorii Rossii IX – nachala XX v. [The history of the Fatherland: people, ideas, solutions. Sketches of history of Russia of the 9-20th centuries], Izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, Moscow, Russia, 76-126.

7.       Zhivov, V. M. (2002), “The History of Russian law as a linguistic and semiotic issue” (in Russ.), Raziskaniya v oblasti istorii i predistorii russkoy kul’tury [Searches in the field of history and prehistory of Russian culture], LRC Publishing House, Moscow, Russia,187-290.

8.       Zimin, A. A. (1991), Vityaz' na rasput'e [Knight at the crossroads], Mysl’, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

9.       Kivelson, V. (2012), Kartografiya carstva: zemlya i ee znachenie v Rossii XVII veka [Cartography of the Kingdom: the land and its value in Russia of the 17th century], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

10.     Kobrin, V. B. (1991), “Ivan the Terrible: The Chosen council or oprichnina?” (in Russ.), Istoriya Otechestva: lyudi, idei, reshebiya. Ocherki istorii Rossii IX – nachala XX v. [The history of the Fatherland: people, ideas, solutions. Sketches of history of Russia of the 9-20th centuries], Izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, Moscow, Russia, 127-162.

11.     Kobrin, V. B. (1991), “The time of troubles – lost opportunities” (in Russ.), Istoriya Otechestva: lyudi, idei, reshebiya. Ocherki istorii Rossii IX – nachala XX v. [The history of the Fatherland: people, ideas, solutions. Sketches of history of Russia of the 9-20th centuries], Izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, Moscow, Russia, 163-185.

12.     Kollmann, N. (2016), Prestuplenie i nakazanie v Rossii rannego Novogo vremeni [Crime and punishment in Russia of the Early Modern Time], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, Moscow, Russia.

13.     Krom, M. M. (2010), “Vdovstvstvuyuschee carstvo”: politicheskij krizis v Rossii 30-40-h godov XVI veka [“Widowhood Kingdom”: the political crisis in Russia in the 30-40-ies of the 16th century], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

14.     Krom, M. M. (2005), “To an understanding of Moscow's "policy" of the 16th century: discourse and practice of late medieval Russian monarchy” (in Russ.), Odissey: Chelovtk v istorii. Vrevya i prostranstvo praktiki, Nauka Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 283-303.

15.     Maskevich, S. (1859), “Maskevich's Diary 1594-1621”, Skazaniya sovremennikov o Dmitrii Samozvance [Tales of contemporaries of Dmitri the Impostor] (in Russ.), Saint Petersburg, Russia, Vol. 1, 13-124.

16.     Melgunov, S. P. (1907), Cerkov’ i gosudarstvo v Rossii (k voprosu o svobode sovesti) [Church and state in Russia (on freedom of conscience)], Izd-vo Tov. I.D. Sytina. (in Russ.).

17.     Nosov, N. E. (1969), Stanovlene soslovno-predstavitel’skih uchrezhdeniy v Rossii. Izyskaniya o zemskoy reforme Ivana Groznogo [Formation of class-representative institutions in Russia. Research on the Zemsky reform of Ivan the Terrible], Nauka, Leningrad, Russia. (in Russ.).

18.     Peck, L. (2016), “For the king not to be generous would be a mistake": a look at patronage in the court of the first stewards in England” (in Russ.), Patron-klientskie otnosheniya v istorii i sovremennosti [Patron-client relations in history and modern times], ROSSPEN, Moscow, Russia, 149-184.

19.     The first message to Kurbskiy (2005), Poslaniya Ivana Groznogo [The Messages of Ivan the Terrible], Nauka Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 9-71. (in Russ.).

20.     Pokrovsky, N. N. (1989), Tomsk 1648-1649 gg. Voevodskaya chast’ i zemskie miry [Tomsk in 1648-1649. The provincial government and provincial worlds], Nauka, Novosibirsk, Russia. (in Russ.).

21.     Smirnov, A. A. (1994), “The State of the fighting nation” (in Russ.), Rodina, 9, 34-38.

22.     Sobranie gosudarstvennyh gramot i dogovorov, hranyaschihsya v Gosudarstvennoy Kollegii inostrannyh del. Chast’ 2-ya [Collection of state certificates and contracts stored in The State College of Foreign Affairs. Part 2] (1819), Tip. Selivanovskogo, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

23.     Tilly, Ch. (2009), Prinuzhdenie, capital i evropeiskie gosudarstva 990-1992 gg. [Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990-1992], Translated by Menskaya, T., Publishing House “Territoriya buduschego”, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

24.     Franklin, S. (2010), Pismennost’, obschestvo i kul’tura v Drevney Rusi [Writing, society and culture in Ancient Rus], Translated by Bulanin, D, Dmitriy Bulanin, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).

25.     Henshall, N. (2003), Mif absolutizma. Peremeny i preemstvennost’ v razvitii zapadnoevropeyskoy monarhii Novogo vremeni [The Myth of Absolutism: Change and Continuity in Early Modern European Monarchy], Translated by Palamarchuk, A., Alteya, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).

26.     Horoshkevich, A. L. (1994), “The State of all Rus” (in Russ.), Rodina [Motherland], 5, 20-26.

27.     Elias, N. (2002), Pridvornoe obshchestvo: Issledovaniya po sotsiologii korolya i pridvornoy aristokratii [Court society: Studies in the sociology of the king and the court aristocracy], LRC Publishing House, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

28.     Yanov, A. L. (2001), Rossiya: u istokov tragedii. 1462-1584. Zametki o prirode proishozhdeniya russkoj gosudarstvennosti [Russia: at the origins of the tragedy. 1462-1584. Notes on the nature of the origin of the Russian statehood], Progress-Tradiciya, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).

29.     Barkey, K. (2008), Empire of Difference. The Ottomans in Comparative Perspective, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

30.     Breen, M. (2005), “Patronage, Politics, and the “Rule of Law” in Early Modern France”, Proceedings of the Western Society for French History, Vol. 33, 95-113.

31.     Carroll, S. (2006), Blood and Violence in Early Modern France. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.

32.     Elliott, J. H. (1992), “A Europe of Composite Monarchies”, Past & Present, 137 (The Cultural and Political Construction of Europe), 48-71.

33.     Halperin, C. J. (2002), “Muscovy as a Hypertrophic State: A Critique”, Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, Vol. 3, 3, 501-507.

34.     Kivelson, V. (2002), “Muscovite “Citizenship”: Rights without Freedom”, The Journal of Modern History, Vol. 74, 3, 465-489.

35.     Kivelson, V. (2002), “On Words, Sources, and Historical Method: Which Truth about Muscovy?”, Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, Vol. 3, 3, 487-499.

36.     Kollmann, N. S. (2012), Crime and Punishment in Early Modern Russia, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

37.     Koenigsberger, H. G. (1978), “Monarchies and Parliaments in Early Modern Europe Dominium Regale or Dominium Politicum et Regale”, Theory and Society, Vol. 5, 2, 191-217.

38.     Lieberman, V. (2009), Strange Parallels. Southeast Asia in Global Context, c. 800–1830, Vol. 2: Mainland Mirrors: Europe, Japan, China, South Asia, and the Islands, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.

39.     Poe, М. (2002), “The Truth about Muscovy”, Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, Vol. 3, 3, 473-486.

40.     “The German State: a Non-Prussian View” (1999), Rethinking Leviathan: The Eighteenth-century State in Britain and Germany, in Brever, J. and Hellmith, E. (ed), Oxford University Press, London-Oxford, UK.  

41.     Rustemeyer, A. (2010), “Systems and Senses: New Research on Muscovy and the Historiography on Early Modern Europe”, Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, Vol. 11, 3, 563-579.

42.     Scribner, R. W. (1987), “Police and the Territorial State in Sixteenth-Century Württemberg”, Politics and Society in Reformation Europe, in Elton, G., Kouri, E., Scott, T. (ed), Palgrave MacMillan, London, UK, 103-120.