"Nobody to take...": Alexander I, reforms and Russian nobility
(Patrick O'Mеara and his "Russian nobility of the times of Alexander I")
The problem of reforms (or revolutions) "from above" in Russia has long been of interest to historians, political scientists, cultural scientists and other specialists studying the development of society and its institutions. Historical experience shows that the success and failure of reforms is determined not only by the actions of the authorities. The position of society and influential groups within it also plays a significant role in this process. In his study of the Russian nobility during the reign of Emperor Alexander I, British historian Patrick O'Mara aimed to provide a political and social portrait of this class. He asked himself along the way: why did Alexander's reforms stall and not develop? The researcher's answer is twofold. On the one hand, he writes that the emperor was unable to find a common language with the nobility and support from it. On the other hand, he shows that the nobility itself en masse was not ready for active participation in political life either in terms of its level of education or intellectual development. The article places O'Mara's book in a broad historical context, compares the findings of the British historian with the results of other researches and emphasizes that the phrase "There is no one to take" attributed to Alexander I really reflects the shortage of professionally trained to the civil service and progressive-minded people. The layer of "enlightened bureaucracy" was too thin and distant from the bulk of the nobility, so ultimately the reforms were unsuccessful, and the new Emperor Nicholas I relied on the training of such personnel. This policy yielded results a quarter of a century later and made the "Great Reforms" of Alexander II possible, but this required a change in the generation of officials and administrators.
While nobody left any comments to this publication.
You can be first.
Averincev, S. S. (2005), Drugoy Rim. Izbrannye stati [Another Rome. Selected articles], Amfora, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Alekseev, A. I. (2019), «Bodroopasny voin Khristov». Iosif Volotskiy i ego sochineniya v svete dannykh sovremennoy nauki [“The Vigorous Warrior of Christ”. Joseph Volotsky and his works in the light of modern science], Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ, Moscow – Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Alekseev, Yu. G. (1991), Gosudar vseya Rusi [Sovereign of All Rus], Nauka, Novosibirsk, Russia (in Russ.).
Alekseev, Yu. G. (2001), Sudebnik Ivana III. Traditsiya i reforma [Code of Law of Ivan III. Tradition and reform], Dmitriy Bulanin, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Bogoslovsky, M. M. (1902), Oblastnaya reforma Petra Velikogo. Provintsii 1719-1727 gg. [Regional reform of Peter the Great. Provinces 1719-1727]. Universitetskaya tipografiya, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Dubrovin, N. F. (2007), Russkaya zhizn v nachale XIX veka [Russian Life at the Beginning of the 19th Century], Publishing House DNK, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Eisenstadt, Sh. N. (2016), “Patron-client relations as a model for structuring social exchange”, Patron-klientskie otnosheniya v istorii i sovremennosti: khrestomatiya, Politicheskaya entsiklopediya, Moscow, Russia, 366-413. (in Russ.).
Ekshtut, S. A. (1998), Na sluzhbe rossiyskomu Leviafanu. Istoriosofskie opyty [In the service of the Russian Leviathan. Historiosophical experiments], Progress-Traditsiya, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Elias, N. Pridvornoe obshchestvo. Issledovaniya po sotsiologii korolya i pridvornoy aristokratii, s Vvedeniem: Sotsiologiya i istoriya [Court society. Research on the sociology of the king and the court aristocracy, with an Introduction: Sociology and history], Yazyki slavyanskoy kultury, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Griffits, D. (2013), Ekaterina II i ee mir: statyi raznykh let [Catherine II and Her World: Articles from Different Years], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Karavashkin, A. V. (2021), Vlast i slovo v srednevekovoy Rusi. Smyslovye urovni polemicheskikh tekstov [Power and Word in Medieval Rus'. Semantic Levels of Polemical Texts]. Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ, Moscow–Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Klyuchevsky, V. O. (1990), “Eugene Onegin and His Ancestors”, Sochineniya v devyati tomakh. T. IX. Materialy raznykh let [Works in Nine Volumes. Vol. IX. Materials from Different Years]. Mysl, Moscow, Russia, 84-101. (in Russ.).
Kollmann, N. S. (2017), The Russian Empire 1450-1801, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Korf, S. A. (1906), Dvoryanstvo i ego soslovnoe upravlenie za stoletie 1762-1855 godov [The Nobility and Its Estate Administration over the Century of 1762-1855], Tipografiya Trenke i Fyusno, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Liven, D. (2000), Aristokratiya v Evrope 1815-1914 [Aristocracy in Europe 1815-1914], Akademicheskiy proekt, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Litvinova, T. F. (2019), «Pomeshchchichiya pravda». Dvoriyanstvo Levoberezhnoy Ukrainy i krestiyanskiy vopros v kontse XVIII – pervoy polovine XIX veka ["Landlord Truth". The Nobility of Left-Bank Ukraine and the Peasant Question in the Late 18th – First Half of the 19th Century], Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Marasinova, E. N. (1994), “The Decembrists: An Aristocratic Fronde in Russia”, Rossiya XXI, 1-2, 96-106. (in Russ.).
Martin, A. (2021), Romantiki, reformatory, reaktsionery. Russkaya konservativnaya mysl i politika v tsarstvovanie Aleksandra I [Romantics, Reformers, Reactionaries. Russian Conservative Thought and Politics during the Reign of Alexander I], Academic Studies Press / Bibliorossika, Boston, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Milyukov, P. N. (1918), Ocherki po istorii russkoy kultury [Essays on the History of Russian Culture], Part 1, Sabasnikovs Publishing House, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Mironov, B. N. (2003), Sotsialnaya istoriya Rossii perioda imperii (XVIII – nachalo XX v.). Genezis lichnosti, demokraticheskoy semi, grazhdanskogo obshchestva i pravovogo gosudarstva [Social History of Russia during the Imperial Period (18th – Early 20th Century). Genesis of the Individual, Democratic Family, Civil Society, and the Rule of Law]. Dmitriy Bulanin, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Mousnier, R. (1973), Social hierarchies, 1450 to the present, Schocken Books, New York.
“On the establishment of factories in Russia, on the examination of craftsmen exported from other States, on their release to the fatherland after the expiration of the terms, under contracts and on the increase in hemp production in Great and Little Russia” (1830), Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire, since 1649. Vol. VII. 1723-1727, Tipografia II Otdeleniya Sobstvennoy Ego Imperatorskogo Velichestva Kantselyarii. Saint Petersburg, 150-151. (in Russ.).
O’Meara, P. (2023), Russkoe dvoryanstvo vremen Aleksandra I [The Russian Nobility in the Age of Alexander I], Translated by A. Shokarev, Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
O’Meara, P. (2019), The Russian Nobility in the Age of Alexander I, Bloomsbury Publishing Plc., London.
Orlovsky, D. (2022), Predely reform. Ministerstvo vnutrennikh del Rossiyskoy imperii v 1802-1881 godax [Limits of reforms. Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Empire in 1802-1881], Academic Studies Press / Bibliorossika, Boston, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Raeff, M. (2000), “Regular police state and the concept of modernism in Europe in the 17th-18th centuries: an attempt at a comparative approach to the problem”, Amerikanskaya rusistika: vekhi istoriografii poslednikh let. Imperatorskiy period [American Russian Studies: Milestones in Historiography of Recent Years. The Imperial Period], Publishing House «Samarskiy Universitet», Samara, Russia, 48-79. (in Russ.).
Ruzhitskaya, I. V. (2009), «Prosveshchennaya byurokratiya» (1800-1860-e gg.) ["Enlightened bureaucracy" (1800-1860s)], Publishing House of the Institute of the Russian Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Pavlov-Silvanskiy, N. P. (1988), Feodalizm v Rossii [Feudalism in Russia], Nauka, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Pamyatniki russkogo prava. Vyp. 8. Zakonodatelnye akty Petra I. Pervaya chetvert XVIII v. [Monuments of Russian law. Issue 8. Legislative acts of Peter I. The first quarter of the 18th century] (1961), Gosyurizdat, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Petrov, K. V. (2008), “Did the Code of Laws of 1497 have the significance of law in its modern sense? (Regarding the article by S.N. Kisterev ‘The Grand Ducal Code of Laws of 1497 and the judicial practice of the first half of the 16th century’)”, Essays on feudal Russia, iss. 12, Alyans-Arxeo, Moscow – Saint Petersburg, 365-382 (in Russ.).
Pikering Antonova, K. (2019), Gospoda Chikhachevy. Mir pomestnogo dvoryanstva v nikolaevskoy Rossii [The Chikhachev Lords. The World of the Landed Nobility in Nicholas's Russia], Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Pravda voli monarsheн [The Truth of the Monarch's Will], (1722), Moskovskaya tipografiya, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Redin, D. A. (2021), “The Charm of ‘Regularity’: a renewed exploration of Peter the Great's 'mental state'. Part 2. ‘The Russian Imperial State’", Dialogue with Time. Almanac of Intellectual History, 75, 315-334 (in Russ.).
Soloviev, S. M. (1994), “History of Russia from Ancient Times. Vol. 25”, Sochineniya.Kn. XIII [Works. Book 13], Mysl, Moscow, Russia, 7-299 (in Russ.).
Toffler, A. (2004), Tretya volna [The Third Wave], AST, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Vitlin, V. E. (2021), V poiskax ideala: predstavleniya o vlasti gosudarya v russkoy publitsistike pervoy treti XVI v. [In Search of the Ideal: Ideas about the Power of the Sovereign in Russian Journalism of the First Third of the 16th Century], Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ, Moscow – Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Voskresenskiy, N. A. (1945), Zakonodatelniye akty Petra I: Redaktsii, proekty zakonov, zametki, doklady, donosheniya, chelobitiya i inostrannye istochniki. T. I. Akty o vysshikh gosudarstvennykh ustanovleniyakh [Legislative Acts of Peter I: Editorial Draft Laws, Notes, Reports, Reports, Petitions, and Foreign Sources. V. I. Acts on the Supreme State Institutions], Publishing House of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow-Leningrad, Russia (in Russ.).
Wortman, R. S. (2004), Vlastiteli i sudii: Razvitie pravovogo soznaniya v imperatorskoy Rossii [Rulers and Judges: The Development of Legal Consciousness in Imperial Russia], Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).