The problem of the vocation of the Varangians and the formation of Russian national identity in the Russian historiography of the 19th century
One of the most important problems that exist in Russian historical science and philosophy, starting with the grandiose, but extremely contradictory Peter's transformations, is the problem of the crisis of identity, the search for a way of their own development, we can say, the struggle between Westernism and identity. The result of such a search is always an increasing interest in the native history, its origins. This interest arose in the 18th and 19th centuries. It is also relevant for modern Russian society. The main questions that are asked here are: have we been backward and dependent on other countries throughout history, what are the origins and nature of state power in our country, what is the special "Russian character". It should be emphasized that unambiguous answers to the above questions were not received in the 18th, 19th, or even 20th and 21st centuries. This is due both to their political nature and general ideological orientation, as well as to the contradictory source data that allow for different interpretations of the events of 862, which are traditionally considered the beginning of the history of Russia. We are talking about the problem of the vocation of the Varangian (the so-called "Varangian question" in historical science) and its understanding in Russian science.
The "Varangian question" in Russian history is a special question. Its objective complexity lies in the complexity and inconsistency of the source base, which includes different-time data on the Varangian and Russ contained in Byzantine, Arab, Western European and, of course, Russian sources, which denote different peoples and social groups by the terms "Varangian" and "Rus", which cannot but cause difficulty in determining the reliable interpretation of the source data. However, an even greater complexity of this issue lies in the confrontation between the two trends that have developed in historical science, Normanism and antinormanism, which does not allow historians who adhere to one or another version to objectively, without bias, consider and evaluate historical data. The solution of the Varangian question is also subjectively connected with the general worldview ideas of historians about the way of development of Russia, its specifics in comparison with the states of the West and the East. This issue is very difficult to solve. Nevertheless, the choice of Russia's development path depends on its decision.
While nobody left any comments to this publication.
You can be first.
Bayer, G. Z. (1767), Sochinenie o varyagakh [Essay about the Varangians], at the Imperial Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Boltin, I. N. (1990), “Notes on ‘The history of antiquity and immersion of Russia in Leclerc’”, Sbornik materialov po istorii istoricheskoy nauki SSSR [Collection of materials on the history of historical science of the USSR], Vysshaja shkola, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Fomin, V. V. (2006), Lomonosov. Geniy russkoy istirii [Lomonosov: The Genius of Russian history], Russkaja panorama, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Gedeonov, S. A. (1876), Varyagi i Rus’. Istoricheskoe issledovanie.Chast’ 2. [Varangians and Rus. Historical research. Part 2], Tipografija Imperatorskoj akademii nauk, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Gubarev, O. L. (2020), “L. S. Klein and ‘Varangian question’”, Lev Kleyn [Putevoditel’]. Sbornik statey pamyati L’va Samuilovicha Kleyna [In the collection: Lev Klein. [Travel guide]. Collection of articles in memory of Lev Samuilovich Klein], Institut istorii material’noy kul’tury RAN, St. Petersburg, Russia, 106-115 (in Russ.).
Karamzin, N. M. (2003), Istoriya gosudarstva Rossiyskogo. Тom 1 [History of the Russian state. Vol. 1], Jeksmo, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Klein, L. S. (2009), Spor o varyagakh. Istoriya protivostoyaniya i argumenty storon [The dispute about the Varangians. The history of the confrontation and the arguments of the parties], Eurasia, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Lomonosov, M. V. (1952), Polnoe Sobranie Sochineniy. Tом 6.Trudy po russkoj istorii, obshhestvenno-ekonomicheskim voprosam i geografii [Complete works. Vol. 6. Works on Russian History, socio-economic issues and geography], Izdatel'stvo Akademii nauk SSSR, Moscow-Leningrad, USSR (in Russ.).
Lomonosov, M. V. (1986), “Remarks on the dissertation of G. F. Miller ‘The origin of the name and the people of Russia’. Report to the office of the Academy of Sciences. 16 September 1749”, Lomonosov, M. V. Izbrannie proizvedeniya. Tom 2. Istorija. Filologija. Pojezija [Lomonosov M. V. Selected works. Vol. 2. History. Philology. Poetry], Nauka, Moscow, Russia, 18-22 (in Russ.).
Maksimovich, M. A. (1837), Otkuda idet Russkaya zemlya [Whence comes the Russian land], Universitetskaja tipografija, Kiev, Russia (in Russ.).
Miller, G. F. (1788), O narodakh izdrevle v Rossii obitavshikh [About the peoples who lived in Russia since ancient times], Tipografija Imperatorskoj akademii nauk, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Moroshkin, F. L. (1840), O znachenii imeni russov i slavyan [On the meaning of the name of the Russ and Slavs], Universitetskaja tipografija, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Moroshkin, F. L. (1842), Issledovaniya o russakh i slavyanakh [Studies on the Russ and Slavs], Tipografija K. Vingebera, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Moshin, V. A. (1931), “The Varyago-Russian question”, Slavia Casopis pro slovanskou filologii. Rocnik X. Sesit 3 [Slavia magazine for Slavic philology. Issue 10. Vol. 3], Prague, (in Russ.).
Pushkin, A. S. (1962), Sobranie sochineniy v 10 tomakh. Тоm 7. Istoriya Pugacheva: Istoricheskie stst’i i materially. Vospominaniya i dnevniki [Collected works in 10 volumes. Volume 7. The history of Pugachev: Historical articles and materials. Memoirs and diaries], Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo hudozhestvennoj literatury, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Russov, S. (1836), O drevnostaykh Rosii. Novye tolki razbor ikh [About the antiquities of Russia. New conversations and analysis of them], St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Senkovsky, O. I. (1834), “Scandinavian Sagas”, Biblioteka dlya chit'ya, zhurnal slovesnosti, nauk, iskusstv, promyshlennosti i mod [Library for reading, journal of literature, sciences, arts, industry and fashion], Vol. 1, Ed. 3, St. Petersburg, Russia, 1-77 (in Russ.).
Shletzer, A. L. (1809), Nestor. Chast’ 1. [Nestor. Part 1], Imperatorskaja tipografija, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Shletzer, A. L. (1816), Nestor. Chast’ 2 [Nestor. Part 2], Imperatorskaja tipografija, St. Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Skrinnikov, R. G. (1997), Istoriya Rusi IX–XVII vv. [Russian history in 9th–17th centuries], “Ves’ mir”, Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).
Skripkin, I. N. (2016), “On the question of the meaning of the term ‘Rus’ in patronymic sources”, Aktual’nye problemy gumanitarnykh i estestvennykh nauk[Actual problems of the humanities and natural sciences], 8-1, 119-124 (in Russ.).
Skripkin, I. N., Shkurat, P. A. (2019), The “Varangian question” as the subject of disputes among historians: approaches, discussions, results, Mezhdunarodnyi zhurnal eksperimental’nogo obrazovaniya [International Journal of Experimental Education]. 4, 13-18 (in Russ.).
Zabelin, I. E. (1876), Istoriya russkoy zhizni s drevneyshikh vremen. Chast’ 1 [History of Russian life since ancient times. Part 1], Moscow, Russia (in Russ.).