Plato's Origins of the Dichotomies of St. Gregory of Nyssa in his Views on the Problems of Apokatastasis
Since the Middle Ages, there have been many theories on the problem of apocatastasis in the works of St Gregory of Nyssa. However, their authors have mainly considered the idea of "all restoration" from different positions, practically without touching the opposing thoughts in the works of Saint Gregory, but they exist and require special analysis. Moreover, there have been practically no studies that have examined the development of opposing thoughts in his works during his lifetime. Partly, the reflection has been carried out from the position of anthropology, to a certain extent the problem of antinomy is considered in the book of the author of this article (2017), but it does not examine ancient sources. Therefore, this work investigates the roots of the problem in ancient Greek philosophy, namely in Plato, and this is its scientific novelty. The subject of the study is therefore the development of the dualism of thought in the works of Saint Gregory of Nyssa, which has its origin in the ancient Greek philosophy of Plato. As the study has shown, Plato's dichotomy is linked to the aporia between the traditional ideas of the ancient Greeks about Hades, where the souls of the dead languish endlessly, and the cosmological system developed by Plato himself. In Plato and St Gregory of Nyssa we also find opposing views on the affirmation of rationally free individuals, both in good and in evil. The first thesis confirms the hypothesis of universal apocatastasis, the second refutes it. Perhaps the Shepherd of Nyssa inherited this dualism of thought from Plato. In addition, the work shows traces of the origin of Origen's ideas about the round shape of the bodies of the heavenly dwellers, about the stars as living beings, about the pre-existence of souls from Platonic philosophy. Plato's cosmological system, as presented in the "Timaeus", is identified here as one of the variants of the concept of universal apocatastasis.
While nobody left any comments to this publication.
You can be first.
Barinov, N. N. (2017), Oproverzhenie ucheniya o vseobshchem spasenii na osnovanii Svyashchennogo Pisaniya, trudov svyatykh ottsov i deyaniy Vselenskikh Soborov. K voprosu o vechnykh mukakh [Refutation of the doctrine of universal salvation based on the Holy Scriptures, the works of the Holy Fathers and the acts of the Ecumenical Councils. On the question of eternal torment], Zorna-Slovo, Ryazan, Russia (in Russ.).
Barinov, N. N. (2016), Uchenie ob apokatastasise v trudakh svyatitelya Grigoriya Nisskogo. K voprosu o vechnykh mukakh [The Doctrine of Apocatastasis in the Works of Saint Gregory of Nyssa. On the question of Eternal Torment], Zorna-Slovo, Ryazan, Russia (in Russ.).
Buxton, R. G. A. (2004). The complete World of Greek Mythology, Thames & Hudson Ltd, London, UK.
Filaret (Gumilevsky) Archbishop (1859), Istoricheskoe uchenie ob ottsakh tserkvi [Historical teaching about the Church Fathers], vol. 2, Printing house of Imperial Academy of Sciences, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Florovsky, G. V. (1935), “On the Resurrection of the Dead”, Pereselenie dush: problema bessmertiya v okkul'tizme i khristianstve, [Transmigration of Souls: The Problem of Immortality in Occultism and Christianity], YMCA Press, Paris, France, 135-167 (in Russ.).
Gregory of Nyssa (1862) Tvorenija svjatogo Grigoriya Nisskogo [The Works of Saint Gregory of Nyssa], vol. 40, V. Gautier’s Printing house, Mosсow, Russia (in Russ.).
Gregory of Nyssa (1871) Tvorenija svjatogo Grigoriya Nisskogo [The Works of Saint Gregory of Nyssa], vol. 45, V. Gautier’s Printing house, Mosсow, Russia (in Russ.).
Homer (1981), Odisseya [The Odyssey], Khudozhestvennaya literatura, Mosсow, USSR (in Russ.).
Likhodedov, A. A. (2006) “The Teaching of Gregory of Nyssa on Apocatastasis in Light of the Ancient Sources of His Anthropology”, Ph.D. Thesis in Philosophy, Mosсow, Russia (in Russ.).
Meyendorff, J. F. (2007), Vvedenie v svyatootecheskoe bogoslovie [Introduction to Patristic Theology], Luchi Sofii, Minsk, Belarus (in Russ.).
Plato (2007), Sochineniya v chetyrekh tomakh [Works in four volumes], vol. 3, part 1, Publishing House of Saint Petersburg University, Publishing house of Oleg Abyshko, Saint Petersburg, Russia (in Russ.).
Plato. (2013), Timaios, I. A. Kollarou & Sias S. A., Athens, Hellenic Republic (in Greek).