Contesting “True Christianity”: Normativity and Religious Identity (Reflections on D.W. Congdon’s Book Who Is a True Christian?Contesting Religious Identity in American Culture, 2024)
The review examines David W. Congdon’s monograph Who Is a True Christian? Contesting Religious Identity in American Culture. The relevance of the book under review lies in the fact that Congdon relocates the question of the boundaries of Christian identity from the sphere of intra-confessional polemics into a broader philosophical, religious-studies, and cultural-political context, demonstrating its connection to the crisis of authority, the politics of memory, the “culture wars,” and contemporary regimes of symbolic exclusion. The novelty of the reviewer’s approach consists in treating the book not only as a work of intellectual history and theological critique, but also as a significant contribution to the discussion of the normativity of religious tradition, its historicity, and its forms of public articulation. The review reconstructs the principal lines of the author’s argument: a critique of prescriptive models of “true Christianity,” an analysis of the transformation of orthodoxy into a cultural and political technology of demarcation, an interpretation of “Christian nationalism” as an extreme form of the normative politicization of religion, and a discussion of Congdon’s proposed concept of “polydoxy.” At the same time, the review identifies the most debatable aspects of the monograph: its tendency toward broad generalizations based on American material and the insufficient elaboration of the positive content of the polydoxy alternative. It is concluded that Congdon’s work constitutes a conceptually rich and heuristically productive study, significant for the broader discussion of the boundaries of religious identity in contemporary culture.
While nobody left any comments to this publication.
You can be first.
Baker, J. O., Perry, S. L. and Whitehead, A. L. (2020), “Keep America Christian (and White): Christian Nationalism, Fear of Ethnoracial Outsiders, and Intention to Vote for Donald Trump in the 2020 Presidential Election”, Sociology of Religion, 81 (3), 272–293, DOI: 10.1093/socrel/sraa015
Congdon, D. W. (2015), The Mission of Demythologizing: Rudolf Bultmann’s Dialectical Theology, Fortress Press, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Congdon, D. W. (2016), The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch, Wipf & Stock Publishers, Eugene, OR, USA.
Congdon, D. W. (2024), Who Is a True Christian? Contesting Religious Identity in American Culture, Cambridge University Press.
Du Mez, K. K. (2020), Jesus and John Wayne: How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation, Liveright Publishing Corporation, New York, NY, USA.
Hellemans, S. (2011), “Religious Orthodoxy as a Modality of ‘Adaptation’”, in Becking, B. (ed.), Orthodoxy, Liberalism, and Adaptation: Essays on Ways of Worldmaking in Times of Change from Biblical, Historical and Systematic Perspectives, Brill, Leiden, the Netherlands; Boston, MA, USA, 9–32.
Lindbeck, G. A. (1984), The Nature of Doctrine: Religion and Theology in a Postliberal Age, Westminster Press, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Lindbeck, G. A. (1997), “The Gospel’s Uniqueness: Election and Untranslatability”, Modern Theology, 13(4), 423–450, DOI: 10.1111/1468-0025.00047
Sykes, S. W. (1984), The Identity of Christianity: Theologians and the Essence of Christianity from Schleiermacher to Barth, Fortress Press, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Watson, E. (2021), “Another Nature of Doctrine: George Lindbeck, Kathryn Tanner and Christian Identities”, Scottish Journal of Theology, 74 (3), 262–273, DOI: 10.1017/S0036930621000429